Wholesale: Products & Services

Open Product/Process CR PC110201-1 Detail

Description Of Change

Project Meetings

Subject: RE: Clarification on Rate Maps/document to determine zones for lo op rates Date: Fri, 18 Jan 2002 17:13:09 -0600 From: "Clauson, Karen L." To: Todd Mead CC: Kathleen Stichter , "Morrisette, Garth M." , Susan Travis Todd: Garth has indicated that we also need the rate center maps as well. Please send copies to Kathy Stichter. Thanks.

01/18/02 Clarification e-mail from Eschelon

Subject: RE: Clarification on Rate Maps/document to determine zones for lo op rates Date: Fri, 18 Jan 2002 17:12:04 -0600 From: "Clauson, Karen L." To: Todd Mead CC: Kathleen Stichter , "Morrisette, Garth M." , Susan Travis I will be in Denver for the CMP Re-design meeting on Tuesday-Thursday. We can discuss on a break, if you would like. Otherwise, you can arrange a call with Kathy Stichter and Garth Morrisette while I am out, if Kathy can find a suitable time for you. Essentially, we are simply asking for the documentation that allows us to determine where our lines (and future lines) fall within the zones that have been established for geographically deaveraged loop rates. For example, a newspaper article in Denver said that Zone 1 (the most dense zone) covered most of the city of Denver. What are the boundaries of that Zone? Do you have a list of wire centers/CLLI code by zone (where the zone is defined by wire centers) or a map that shows these zones? We need this information for AZ and CO. I am copying Susan Travis of WCOM, because she had this same request, and she may have other states.

01/18/02 E-mail with AT&T mailing address

Subject: RE: Your Address Date: Fri, 18 Jan 2002 12:50:10 -0500 From: "Van Meter, Sharon K, NCAM" To: "Todd Mead" CC: "Saunders, Craig" Todd, Thanks for the reminder. 1875 Lawrence St. Room 8-15 Denver, CO 80205 Thanks for your help. Sharon Van Meter Western Region LSAM 303-298-6041 303-540-1637 (pager)

--Original Message-- From: Todd Mead [mailto:tmead@qwest.com] Sent: Friday, January 18, 2002 10:42 AM To: Van Meter, Sharon K, NCAM Cc: Saunders, Craig Subject: Your Address Sharon, Please send me you mailing address and we will send you a copy of the map you requested. Thanks Todd

01/09/02 E-mail from Qwest responding to Eschelon e-mail on Qwest response content

Subject: Re: Qwest Rate Center Maps Date: Wed, 09 Jan 2002 16:09:55 -0700 From: Todd Mead Organization: Qwest Communications International, Inc. To: "Clauson, Karen L." CC: "Van Meter, Sharon K, NCAM" , jmschu4@qwest.com, susan.a.travis@wcom.com, "Saunders, Craig" , "Stichter, Kathleen L." Karen, Yes! The Qwest response presented at next week's CMP meeting will encompass the information you refer to below. Thanks Todd

01/09/02 E-mail from Qwest asking for AT&T address to forward map example.

Subject: Re: Qwest Rate Center Maps Date: Wed, 09 Jan 2002 16:07:41 -0700 From: Todd Mead Organization: Qwest Communications International, Inc. To: "Van Meter, Sharon K, NCAM" CC: jmschu4@qwest.com, susan.a.travis@wcom.com, klclauson@eschelon.com, "Saunders, Craig" Sharon, The map the Qwest individual referred to in the CMP meeting is the same as the example Worldcom sent us. Sharon, if you can send me your address I will make sure a copy is sent to you for your review. Thanks Todd

01/04/02 E-mail from Eschelon requesting additional information on Qwest response content

Subject: RE: Qwest Rate Center Maps Date: Fri, 4 Jan 2002 11:26:00 -0600 From: "Clauson, Karen L." To: Todd Mead , "Van Meter, Sharon K, NCAM" CC: jmschu4@qwest.com, susan.a.travis@wcom.com, klclauson@eschelon.com, "Saunders, Craig" , "Stichter, Kathleen L." Todd: Thanks for the helpful response. Since Sharon asked specifically about the rate center maps, I wasn't sure that your response below deals with the Distribution Area (DA) maps requested by Eschelon. Will we be getting the DA maps at the January meeting? Also, at the meeting in December, we discussed whether the CLECs were actually requesting the correct items to meet their objectives (e.g., being able to identify customers in zones for geographically deaveraged rates). I believe this caem up because Qwest said that it didn't know if it had maps of the type requested. If not, then Qwest must look at something else to make these determinations. We asked that, if we had not requested the documentation used by Qwest for this purpose, that such documentation also be produced. Have you determined yet whether Qwest has different documents/maps and, if so, will that be provided at the January meeting? Thanks, Karen

01/04/02 E-mail response to AT&T

From: Todd Mead [SMTP:tmead@qwest.com] Sent: Friday, January 04, 2002 11:14 AM To: Van Meter, Sharon K, NCAM Cc: jmschu4@qwest.com; susan.a.travis@wcom.com; klclauson@eschelon.com; Saunders, Craig Subject: Re: Qwest Rate Center Maps Sharon, Thanks for your e-mail. At the December CMP meeting, we had a general clarification on this CR where you presented the business reasons for submitting this CR and then the Qwest SME's asked you several questions pertaining to the exact nature of information you were after with these rate center maps. The following are notes I documented from the December CMP clarification meeting: - What states you wanted maps for (Washington, Utah, Colorado, Oregon, Minnesota, Arizona & New Mexico) - What level of detail (you want to be able to see what rate center a specific address is located in) - What format you are after (CLECs prefer electronic, however hard copy would do) - Whether you wanted to only see major metro areas i.e.. Denver, Aurora, Smokey Hills etc. CLECs agreed to this - Eschelon wanted to know if these maps would show how each customer is being served i.e. RSU (Qwest responded they would not and Eschelon responded that they may submit a separate CR). - Worldcom wanted to know if the maps show the CILLI detail (they had some examples from previous USWest maps). We have since contacted LeiLani and she has forwarded a copy of these old maps to the Qwest SME to review to help their response preparation. - You also want the response to include the process for getting these maps updated At the January CMP meeting (01/16/02) Qwest will present their response to your CR. The Qwest team is currently working on this response and I will e-mail it to you (plus Eschelon and Worldcom) as soon as I receive it from the Qwest SME. The response will also be posted to the CMP database and published on the web no later than next Friday (01/11/02). If I have missed something here, I would be more than happy to discuss this with you. You can call me anytime today to discuss this. Regards Todd

01/04/02 E-mail from AT&T requesting map examples

Subject: Qwest Rate Center Maps Date: Fri, 4 Jan 2002 10:49:43 -0500 From: "Van Meter, Sharon K, NCAM" To: CC: , , Todd, I haven't heard anything about the deliver of the Rate Center Maps. It was my understanding that you would contact me and deliver some maps for my review. Please advise. Sharon Van Meter Western Region LSAM 303-298-6041 303-540-1637 (pager)

12/18/01 e-mail from Worldcom to Qwest

Todd, Sure, I will put one in the mail today. LeiLani Hines Worldcom Carrier Management

12/18/01 e-mail from Qwest to Worldcom

Leilani, The Qwest SME would like to see the copy of the map you have. Could you please send him one? Thanks, Todd

> From: Stichter, Kathleen L. > Sent: Friday, November 16, 2001 3:18 PM > To: 'mbelt@qwest.com' > Subject: PC110201-1 > > Mike, > Qwest has a web site http://www.qwest.com/iconn/ that a CLEC can go to and > click on Outside Plant Jobs Greater than $100K to get information on the > build jobs Qwest is planning. Once at this web page the details Qwest > gives are: > State, WireCenter, Job #, Fiber/Cooper, Quantity, Location i.e. DA/CLLI, > Ready for Service and Completion Date. The information populated in the > Location field is either CLLI or DA (Distribution Area). The DA data is a > number i.e. 310211. This number, for the distribution, means nothing to > Eschelon without a map detailing the bounderies down to street level > detail of the specific distribution area. > Thanks > > Kathy Stichter > ILEC Relations Manager > Eschelon Telecom Inc

3:00 p.m. (MDT) / Thursday 16th Nov 2001 Clarification Meeting Conference Call

Attendees: Sharon Van Meter / AT&T Matt Kruzic / Qwest Jacob Barlow / Qwest Jan Attebarry / Qwest Craig Saunders / Qwest Mary Anderson / Qwest Michael Belt / Qwest Kathy Stichter / Eschelon (called later) Tom Dixon / Worldcom (called later)

Review Requested (Description of) Change: AT&T – Qwest Rate Center maps to be public information to the CLEC Community Eschelon & Worldcom would like the DA and CLLI Maps also included with this CR.

Products Impacted - LNP

Identify/Confirm CLEC’s Expectation - Yes the expectations of the CR are understood, need to clarify the issue of Proprietry Qwest information.

CenturyLink Response

Sharon Van Meter Manager AT&T 1875 Lawrence St. Denver, CO 80205

SUBJECT: Qwest’s Change Request Response - CR # PC110201-1 Qwest Rate Center Maps

REQUEST: Qwest determines the Rate Centers. AT&T needs to mirror the Rate Center areas for residential LNP. What is the process for obtaining Rate Center Maps from Qwest?

Additional clarifications/requests: Requested maps at a street level detail. Requested maps for MSA’s in Arizona, Colorado, Washington, Utah, Oregon, Minnesota, & New Mexico Prefer electronic, however paper will do. Requested maps at a level to determine DA areas. Requested maps at a CLLI level detail. Requested a process to update maps.

RESPONSE: Qwest has provided, on the Qwest Wholesale web site, the same rate center maps that Qwest uses and updates on a quarterly basis. The URL is:

www.qwest.com/wholesale/network/ratecentermaps.html

Qwest does not solely rely upon rate center maps to determine number portability. Qwest, as well as other companies, relies upon the Local Exchange Routing Guide (LERG) as the official guide to determine the portability of a number. Qwest determines whether a number is available for porting by looking at the customers switch information, both from and to, which reflects the serving rate center. As determined by the FCC, Qwest does not permit the porting of the numbers between two different rate centers.

Currently the Rate Center maps used by Qwest and provided on the wholesale website do not have the capability to provide wire center street level detail. Maps of DA’s are available through the Qwest Wholesale web site by following the process outlined under the URL:

www.qwest.com/wholesale/pcat/remotecollocation.html

Requesting multiple DA’s in a particular wire center will enable CLEC’s to ascertain the description of the wire center boundary.

In regard to the request for maps where Qwest plans fiber and copper jobs greater than $100,000, Qwest has plot maps that are available for review as outlined in SGAT section 10.8.2.4. Qwest agrees to provide CLEC access to relevant plats upon receiving a bona fide request for such information as stated in the SGAT.

Sincerely,

Craig Saunders Staff Advocate Policy & Law Qwest

CC: Barry Orrel, Director Legal Issues, Qwest Jim Eitel, Director Legal Issues, Qwest Lydia Eiguren, Senior Director Business Development, Qwest John Hayat, Staff Advocate Policy & Law, Qwest Mary Retka, Director Legal Issues, Qwest